PS. Today I will be trying out William Butala's Yay or Nay review system.
Yay,
New York Islanders Chris Hengel
This is Chris' first concept on HCI, so let's cut to the cheese!
The colo(u)r balance on the away jersey! Minus the numbers
The grey element kept in the 3rd
The tie down collars
The orange numbers on the black jersey
The filled in yoke on the third jersey
Nay,
First, the presentation. The alternate gets lost because the background is so dark. Try using a light grey back ground.
The spacing of the numbers. The numbers seem too far apart.
While were on the topic of numbers, I think the away numbers should be Blue, and the home numbers be White.
The NOB font. It seems childish. Try using a arial or block font instead.
Using the same template for all 3 jerseys. The point of a third jersey is to be different. Not just a recolo(u)red Home/Away jersey. Check out our templates page for some great options!
Overall,
I liked the colo(u)r balance in the jerseys, not as much the numbers. I also loved the yokes on all the jerseys, but aspeicialy the 3rd. That's really all I have to say about the jerseys, so...
Concept Rating, 8/10
Team Turkey (LOL) Jake88
Jake88 brings us a concept for the HJC bottom 10 comp. Go vote for it! And my Isreal one! And Justin's South Africa one!
Yay,
The wordmark
The crest
The striping
The yoke on the home, the shoulder patches on the away
The socks
The pants logo
Nay,
The small NOB
The fake laces. Not Jake but Nike
Overall,
Jake brings us a amazing concept where (for once) I'm not complaining!
Concept Rating, 9.9/10
Hey guys! Thanks for reading! What do you think of Butala's Review system? It sure makes it easier for me! Tell me what you think in the comments!
Again, Thanks for reading!!!
Caden
I don't see how that font is "childish" to you, in my opinion that font is more "mature" than the Arial that you suggested. That font is just a block font with too many outlines. Also I don't think that Justin sent his South Africa concept in...
ReplyDeleteThe font looked like a bubble font to me.
Delete